Perspectives

Counting visitors is straightforward. Understanding their economic value requires a closer examination of the numbers. Photographer: Jakub Żerdzicki | Unsplash.
Counting heads
By Thomas Osborne
Briefly …
The tourism industry celebrates visitor numbers, but when will it recognise the true economic value of those travelling solo?
For an industry that prides itself on understanding its customers, tourism has developed a remarkably unsophisticated habit of defining their value. Record passenger numbers, record hotel occupancy, record visitor arrivals and record tourism expenditure are routinely celebrated as measures of success. More, apparently, is better. Except that more customers do not necessarily mean greater economic value.
The distinction is between volume and yield. Visitor numbers tell us how many people arrive, while yield concerns the economic return those visitors generate. Expenditure per visitor, expenditure per night and the benefits retained by local businesses offer different perspectives on tourism’s contribution. The industry already measures many of these things, but its enthusiasm for announcing record arrivals can overshadow a more demanding question about the value generated by different kinds of travellers.
And there is a contradiction buried within this devotion to numbers. It concerns a category of traveller that has rarely fitted comfortably into the industry’s commercial calculations: me. For an industry accustomed to selling rooms to couples, filling coaches with groups and calculating profitability through occupancy and capacity, I present an inconvenient mathematical proposition. One room, one passenger and one booking, occupying a cell on an Excel spreadsheet that might otherwise have accommodated two people.
The familiar commercial response is the single supplement, a particularly revealing expression of an industry that has traditionally treated my travelling alone as a deviation from its preferred arrangement. While the economics of accommodation and group travel are legitimate considerations, the assumptions surrounding them deserve considerably more scrutiny than they generally receive.
Am I a less valuable customer simply because I am travelling solo? Consider the expenditure of another independent traveller on a recent Australian journey into the Northern Territory. Over 11 days, this individual committed AUD$8,099 to travel services, with expenditure distributed across several sectors of the tourism economy.
“Am I a less valuable customer simply because I am travelling solo?”
Accommodation accounted for $1,779, commercial flights for $1,042, rail travel for $2,490, organised tours for $2,529 and an additional scenic flight for $259. These figures exclude personal purchases, meals not included in the bookings, local transport and other incidental expenditure. This is one traveller, one booking party and more than $8,000 in confirmed expenditure before those additional costs are considered.
No travelling companion was required to generate that business, nor was the expenditure confined to a single operator. The bookings supported accommodation providers, airlines, rail services, tour operators and the businesses involved in delivering those experiences. Not every dollar necessarily remained within the destination, but the commercial value of the purchases is undeniable. One example cannot establish the spending behaviour of an entire market, although it does demonstrate why the number of people travelling together is an inadequate measure of an individual customer’s value.
There is also an inconsistency in how the industry accommodates individual customers. Airlines routinely sell individual seats without imposing a surcharge simply because the passenger is travelling alone. Rail operators sell individual tickets, museums and galleries admit individual visitors, and restaurants serve customers who arrive without companions. In these circumstances, one person is a perfectly legitimate economic unit. Yet when that same person books accommodation or joins certain organised tours, travelling alone can suddenly become a commercial disadvantage.
I often find myself wondering why the cost of travelling alone has, by default, become my problem to solve. I might stay longer, visit outside peak periods, spend more readily with local businesses, explore places beyond established tourism circuits or purchase experiences that would never feature in a conventional package itinerary. Equally, I might do none of those things, which is precisely the point. My value cannot be reliably determined by the number of people attached to my booking.
“I often find myself wondering why the cost of travelling alone has, by default, become my problem to solve.”
Yet much of the industry’s commercial architecture continues to reward volume and capacity rather than the individual characteristics of its customers or the contribution their visits make to a destination. It is an extraordinarily blunt instrument for an industry that prides itself on understanding consumer behaviour.
Solo travellers have spent years negotiating a commercial landscape that frequently regards them as incomplete couples, inconvenient booking configurations or spare capacity to be filled when circumstances dictate. Gap fillers, rather than customers whose individual spending patterns and commercial potential warrant serious consideration.
The more revealing question is not whether solo travellers are inherently more valuable than anybody else, but whether the industry has properly calculated what it stands to gain by understanding them. Their preferences, purchasing decisions and patterns of expenditure may reveal opportunities that conventional volume-driven models have failed to recognise.
Perhaps the next great advance in tourism will come not from persuading more people to travel, but from finally understanding the people who already do. Because counting heads is easy. Knowing what they’re worth, to the industry and to the places they visit, is an entirely different proposition.
